My attempt at honesty in motherhood

Saturday, November 15, 2008

From A Mormon Who Supports Gay Marriage

In the past few months, gay marriage has become a hot topic. Proposition 8 in California has been a highly contested issue. As I'm sure most people know, Mormons have also been in the news lately. Most of this publicity has been related to the church's stance/actions for passing Proposition 8. While the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints does not typically get involved in politics, it did in California. The LDS church advocates democracy and does not espouse itself with any political party or candidate. It does, however, reserve the right to speak out on political issues it deems important. Gay marriage is apparently a very important issue. Church members in California were urged to donate their resources, money and time to an organization dedicated to passing Prop 8. Church leaders called their members forward urging action. Members responded. A NYT article titled, Mormons Tipped Scale in Ban on Gay Marriage, provided enough details to make obvious how strongly Mormons felt about this issue. In the end, Proposition 8 passed, ammending the Constitution to state that marriage should be between a man and a woman. This is what church leaders hoped for. I am a Mormon. Right now, I am a Mormon ashamed of my church. I realize that I am in the minority. I realize that there aren't many other members of my church who believe that marriage is not something that should only be afforded to heterosexual couples, but rather to all couples, same-sex or not. It is NOT MY RIGHT, nor anybody elses, to tell two women, both adults and in a consenting relationship, that they cannot get married. That is NOT UP TO ME. I would like to say, though, that "before it accepted the invitation to join broad-based coalitions for the amendments, the Church knew that some of its members would choose not to support its position" (from an official News Release put out by the LDS church). I may be in the minority, but that is my right. Members who disagree will not be excommunicated, etc. There are other people with whom I attend church here in Madison, who share my opinions on gay marriage. So I'm not the only one. We have discussed and dissected this issue until we were blue in the face. I have contemplated leaving the church, banning my children from attending. I have thought that maybe I'd just keep trucking along, hoping (blindly) that this would someday work out. What I've come to realize, though, is that if I stop going to church, if I stop my children from going, I will take away a tiny piece of diversity and difference that my views/my family provide to our church. I love the church. I love the foundation it gives my life, the hope it provides me for this life and the next. But I will not allow myself to hide in a corner. I may be one of the only ones, but I will share my views. I will speak out and advocate for gay rights, for what I believe is right. I will teach my children these same things. When I stand before my two aunts who are lesbian, my friends who are gay, I will not be ashamed. But I will tell them that there ARE Mormons who support them. I am one of them, and I am not afraid to say it out loud. I know that this is an issue that brings up deep emotions on both sides. These are my beliefs. I am entitled to them, just like those who disagree with me are entitled to theirs. Nobody should be punished or persecuted for speaking their mind, no matter which side of the issue they fall on. I welcome comments, but I ask for respect--please remember that we all feel strongly about this. I hope that friendship can rise above disagreement and that love and respect will prevail.

6 comments:

  1. I'm going to be brave and be the first to comment. I have to say that I personally disagree with your position, but the only thing that really saddened me when I read this was that you had thought about leaving the church. Do you take issue with the church's doctrinal stance on homosexuality or with its political promotion of this issue?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Once again, Emily, may I tell you how proud I am to be your mother?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am so proud of you. Tolerance is American. Keep speaking out. Love, Dad

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mandi, thank you for commenting! I appreciate your courage in standing up for your beliefs. I am touched by you saying that the only thing that saddened you was that I had thought about leaving the church. You are a true friend and I'm so glad to know that despite our differences, we can still care about each other. (I really was worried about it.)

    To answer your question, I take issue with both the church's doctrinal stance and with their political involvement. What really got me fired up and upset this time, though, was definitely the level of political involvement. I struggle to see how the church can say in one breath that they know that some members will disagree with their position and that we should all vote according to our own beliefs, while in the next breath the church joins a coalition to ban gay marriage and encourages all its members to participate actively. It just seems hypocritical to me.

    Does that answer your question? Thanks again for being part of my conversation--I am always interested in the other side of the story.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm in a similar place you are, Emily. I have four gay employees and love them all. And I am concerned with the position the church has taken...skirting carefully directly supporting Prop. 8 while encouraging members to do everything they can to pass it.

    I have spent a lot of time praying about it...the answer I've received over and over is to love others and be patient.

    I'm not sure leaving the church is the answer. When I was in grad school I was frustrated by the conservative rhetoric, and felt out of place. I felt, however, if I left, two things would happen. First, the church would become more conservative, and as I love the gospel, I didn't want to see it shanghai'ed by ultra-conservatives. Secondly, I believe in the doctrines of the church and didn't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater (a trenchant but unpleasant metaphor).

    I really think the church needs people like you who can love others while disagreeing with their opinions, a talent that is somewhat rare these days.

    So love and be patient...it'll all work out. Peace, DB

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well, you know I’m with you… the church’s involvement in prop 8 and position on gay marriage in general drives me insane. I’ve had my ups and downs in my faith, particularly since my life doesn’t fit in the mormon mold. What keeps me in the church, like you, is that I believe in the very basic gospel doctrines. They make up my foundational beliefs for my life.
    But there are so many things that lie outside those basic beliefs and are less clear. One of the most challenging tasks we have in life is to identify actual truth. To distinguish it from cultural beliefs, traditions, biases, etc. It is through the process of having our beliefs challenged that we are forced to figure out if we believe something because it is actually true or just because it is what we were told/had always believed. This is why I think it is so important to have a diversity of ideas in the church. It is through discussion and searching that we get closer to the truth. As uncomfortable as it is to be in the minority, everyone benefits when you speak out. So keep it up!

    ReplyDelete